New York Federal Court Grants Permanent Injunction to Cure Unconstitutional Conditions at ICE Facility
by David M. Reutter
On September 24, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York converted a preliminary injunction that addressed confinement conditions at a federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) facility into a permanent injunction. The Court’s order prohibits ICE from housing detainees in overcrowded conditions, requires ICE to provide sanitary conditions, clothing, meals and offer confidential legal calls.
The Court’s order was entered in a class action lawsuit that challenged conditions within ICE’s facility at 26 Federal Plaza in New York City. On September 17, 2025, the Court entered a preliminary injunction that required ICE to improve conditions for immigrant detainees. After reviewing the full evidentiary record and arguments of the parties, District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan found the class was entitled to a permanent injunction.
At a May 2026 bench trial, the Court was presented with evidence showing that, despite its preliminary injunction, ICE was holding detainees in inhuman, unsanitary overcrowded conditions for weeks without beds, showers or medical care. ICE also banned in-person legal visits, as well as confidential exchange of legal documents, confidential legal video or phone communication.
The order began by addressing overcrowding. Evidence showed that ICE held 100 or more detainees in the facility’s holding area. To relieve overcrowding, the Court restricted the number of detainees that may be held in holding areas and cells. Living areas must provide at least 50 square feet of floor space per detainee, excluding bathroom areas. The order limits ICE to holding only 27 detainees in its holding areas.
The Court then tackled confinement conditions. For any detainee held overnight, a mattress, pillow and blanket must be provided. The temperature inside the building must be maintained between 68- and 74-degrees Fahrenheit. Living areas must be cleaned three times daily. Detainees must also be provided hygienic materials to include toilet paper, paper towels, soap, toothpaste, a toothbrush, feminine hygienic products and clean clothing. Three meals that meet U.S. recommended daily nutrition allowances must be provided to detainees.
ICE must also conduct an initial medical screening. Additionally, detainees must be provided with medical care and necessary medications. Detainees must be provided prescribed medications they possess or which are brought by family members or an attorney.
Within one hour of placement in a holding room or four hours after request by a detainee or the detainee’s attorney, ICE must allow detainees to make a confidential legal call or visit. If necessary, interpretation services must be provided. Pro bono legal service phone numbers must be posted. All detainees must be provided, and sign receipt of, a rights card detailing the Court’s order.
Lawyers for the class were pleased with the Court’s order, but they were critical of the government’s tactics. “While we applaud the court’s decision to issue permanent protections requiring ICE to improve conditions at 26 Federal Plaza, it shouldn’t take a federal lawsuit to get the government to comply with the law,” said Carmen Iguina Gonzalez, deputy director of immigrant detention for the American Civil Liberties Union’s (ACLU) National Prison Project. “As our legal teams have argued before, the conditions at this facility were entirely a crisis of ICE’s own making.”
The ACLU, in the latest installment of a continuing series of reports, argued that the “Trump administration is using mass deportation as the pretext and mechanism to attack civil liberties and structural democratic safeguards at an unprecedented scale and speed.” The ACLU warned that the mass deportation effort pulls from an “authoritarian playbook” that expands the administration’s police and executive power.
The ACLU also noted that in addition to the administration’s violation of rights to free speech and free assembly and the denial of due process, the administration violates court orders requiring compliance with the law. See: Murcado v. Mullin, USDC (S.D.N.Y.), Case No. 25-cv-06568.
Additional source: ACLU

